Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ron Ruthfield's avatar

As a Jewish American and as one who seeks to live out the calling of a conservative mind and spirit, I found myself deeply moved—indeed, pierced—by your column. You have captured in unforgettable words the tension at the very heart of our age: whether man will humble himself before the Eternal, or enthrone the fragile self as god.

Your meditation on memento mori resounds in my own soul, for Judaism too instructs us to remember always that our lives are but a breath, and that our days are numbered by the Almighty. “Teach us to number our days, that we may gain a heart of wisdom” (Psalm 90). The wisdom that Charlie Kirk embodied, and that you have so eloquently recognized, is precisely this: that death is not to be forgotten, not to be hidden under comforts and distractions, but to be faced with courage, faith, and reverence.

The journey you describe is palpable, it tugs at the sinews of humanity that bind us together no matter our enduring faiths. I too struggle daily with the conviction that there must be better worlds beyond where we live. Our prophets, our sages, and our martyrs all testified to this: that we walk not merely in the shadow of death but also in the shadow of eternity. That is why your words stir so profoundly—they remind us that to forget death is to forget God, and to forget God is to destroy life itself.

You are right to say that conservatism is the philosophy that remembers. Judaism is nothing if not the discipline of memory. We remember creation. We remember Sinai. We remember Egypt. We remember exile, destruction, martyrdom—and we remember life. Memory is our faith’s marrow, and to conserve is to carry forward that memory into each new age, lest we be seduced by illusions of autonomy, pleasure, and self-worship.

The dichotomy you have presented may indeed seem, on the surface, too neat—life versus death, God versus self. But it is precisely such clarity that serves as a masterful beginning. It unmasks what modern sophisticates often obscure: that there are ultimately only two ways before us, the way of life and the way of death. Our societies and our belief systems may differ in doctrine, yet all of us who acknowledge something higher than ourselves begin to merge at this crossroads. Either we will build a civilization where eternal truths order human life, or we will descend into a chaos where appetites rule and the self reigns as a cruel idol.

Charlie Kirk’s assassination, as you write, was not merely political but theological. As a Jew, I cannot help but see in this a familiar tragedy: the silencing of voices who dare to call men back to truth, the attempt to erase witnesses whose lives embody conviction. It is an ancient stain on the human condition—that we so often answer truth not with humility but with violence.

And yet, even in the blood of the righteous, even in the cruel interruption of a life of faith, there is testimony. Charlie’s faith in the Resurrection, and his refusal to bow to fear, is a reminder to us all that courage is only possible when one knows that death does not have the final word. Judaism, too, testifies that the Author of Life will one day wipe away every tear, and that the covenant of eternity is not broken by the grave.

Your words compel us to remember that our task, if we are to remain human, is not to train ourselves to kill those with whom we disagree, but to train ourselves to think, to build, to conserve, to remember, and to bless. What a stain it is upon humanity that in every age we must relearn this lesson. And what a mercy that in every age, God raises up those who refuse to forget death, and thus insist on the sanctity of life.

Your column is more than commentary; it is a call. And as a Jew and as a conservative, I add my voice to it with gratitude and reverence.

Expand full comment
Judy Ogden's avatar

Amen and Amen! 🙏May God open hearts and minds and may He work through us to spread the truth of the Gospel to all around us…and may Charlie’s life and legacy as a Christian martyr inspire us as we seek God in His Word and follow His plan and Charlie’s stated desire (as per his sweet, grieving wife Erika) “to make heaven crowded.” There is no promise that it will be easy—may God grant us the same courage and perseverance of Charlie and all who’ve stood their ground for Christ. We know eternity is at stake. ✝️🙏🙌

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts